Iggulden wrote:
Welcome to the site, Caspar, Meg, Vaughn and Mike.
Quote:
the book on the American football player-turned soldier who was killed in Afghanistan, Pat Tillman. Its a very interesting read so far.
What was the title? I remember that. I know he's been criticised for his sacrifice, but I thought he was an inspiration, that man.
Conn
The title of the book is Where Men Win Glory. Its not horrible, but its certainly no masterpiece. I feel like the author really digs a little too deeply into Pat's life. Its not intrusive or anything, just stuff that I don't really seem to be able to bring myself to care too much about, so I have caught myself skipping some of the accounts of specific football games. I was hoping that the book would deal more with what happened in Afghanistan, and it does do that, but its the getting there that makes the book feel lengthier than it may have needed to feel. The one thing the author really does do a great job of is in his explanation of the tribal alliances and the differences in the various factions and who is aligned with the US and who is not, and why. He also goes into lengthy detail about the Soviet incursion into Afghanistan, as well as Bin Laden's repeated attempts to force American intervention into the nation. Pretty brilliant on the part of Bin Laden, but then again, no one in his right mind ever accused Bin Laden of being an idiot.
I don't see how anyone could criticize Tillman for his sacrifice. In the end, we all have to choose our own path, and he chose his, knowing full well the ramifications. Of course, I'm sure he never considered being murdered out in the field, but then anything can and does happen in war. Pat was an adrenaline junkie and fiercely patriotic. Quite frankly, both of our nations could use more men like him. I'm about halfway through the book right now, and like I said, its not one of my favorite reads, but it'll do until some of the Clavell books I ordered come in (I bought those based on your well known love for Clavell by the way).
On another note, I was wondering the other day while I was working if you had ever considered doing a series on some of the history of Japan, particularly the Edo period up through the transformation of Japan during the Meiji period. There was so much going on during those 300+ years, it couldn't help but be sweeping and b****. Perhaps a start to the series prior to the Edo as Japan fights off the invading Mongols with the help of the Divine Wind...